Jews
of Munkacs
I
became responsible for selecting books to buy for the Holocaust
Centre library. We have a fair selection of books, and some
irreplaceable old books published soon after the Second World War,
but our library is under used. We should make these books available
through the library system to readers and scholars wherever they are
in New Zealand, but the challenge
of doing this proved so far too hard. Now Yad Vashem published a new
book, Days of Ruin: The Jews of Munkacs during the Holocaust, by
Raz Segal. Would we be justified in getting it? The story of the fate of the Jews of Munkacs sheds
interesting light on the understanding of the Holocaust. Though
Munkacs was an isolated town in the Sub-Carpathian border region
between Ukraine, Slovakia, Romania and Hungary,
where the borders kept shifting, the its hasidic Jewish community was
renowned throughout the orthodox Jewish world. Jews were materially
poor in an impoverished backward, underdeveloped part of Europe, but
they had an amazingly rich Hasidic cultural tradition that made a
great impact on current hasidism. Munkacs was part of the
Austro-Hungarian Empire until the end of the First World War. After
that it was incorporated into the newly established Czechoslovakia.
In 1938 it was annexed by Hungary. Had this not happened the Jews of
Munkacs, part of Slovakia after the Czechoslovakia was dismembered,
would have been among the first victims of the Holocaust. As it was,
as part of Hungary, they were safe until the German occupation in
1944. At first they welcomed their incorporation in Hungary, but they
faced increasing antisemitic legislation and restrictions on their
livelihood. Jewish men were conscripted into the Jewish unarmed
military labour force, but this in many cases saved them from
deportation and enabled them to survive. Some could take the
opportunity to emigrate. Thus the Munkacs hasidic court survived in
Brooklyn, New York. To understand the Holocaust, it is important to
consider the shifting borders of Eastern Europe and the accident of
being on one side or the other of these borders. If we bought the book on the Jews of
Munkacs who would read it? Who would care? On the other hand ours
might be the only copy of the book in New Zealand. Perhaps there is
someone out there interested in this remote border land of Europe who
might want to read about it. Would it shed light on the conflicts
in the region?
The web site seems to have eaten my comments, I'm writing it again - apologies if you have 2 similar comments.....
ReplyDeleteInteresting that the "Backward" communities of Munkacs and Satmar, or the Judaism of the Chatam Sofer which were worlds apart from the "Civilized" Neolog traditions that you grew up with, but Neolog Judaism never took root outside of Hungary, and today is almost unheard of outside of Budapest, but the courts of Munkacs and Satmar managed to replant themselves in the New World (Israel and New York) and today and not only much larger than they ever were, but are more widely known and regarded within the Jewish community.
Compare the "before" and after pictures comparing the pre-war Munkacser with the current Rebbe:
Before:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LP7pHzJCnGg&spfreload=10
After:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLamAdKoP2s
And don't forget the Mitzva Tanz (if mixed dancing doesn't bother you):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QFHbGyne8hI&spfreload=10