China
and in the context of world history
Recently
I attended a talk about Liang
Qichao, the Chinese scholar, journalist and politician, and it
brought home to me how little I know about Chinese history. With this
in mind, I read Rana Mitter's A Bitter Revolution: China's
Struggle with the Modern World. Mitter
sets what was going on in China in the context of what was happening
in the rest of the world, a very broad approach to understanding
history. China was the victim of imperialism since the Opium Wars of
1839. The British, and later the French and the Germans, and
ultimately the Japanese, saw China as a backward country there to be
exploited. In 1919, the Treaty of Versailles, where China failed to
regain the Shandong province that was until then occupied by the
Germans, brought home the high-handed imperialist view of China, and
the resentment over this issue lead to the May 4 uprising. The
protest was against imperialism, and colonialism. The protesters
demanded modernization, democracy, and the end of Confucian
domination of the Chinese social order. These demands kept recurring
throughout the turbulent history of twentieth century China, although
the meaning of these terms was understood differently by
Nationalists, Communists, and other reformers. Just as in the rest of
the world, particularly in Europe, modernization could mean the
tradition of eighteenth and nineteenth century enlightenment,
empirical science, and a rejection of religion, superstition, and
myths about nationhood. It could also mean the exact opposite, a
romantic view of the myths of the 'volk' the primitive wisdom of the
simple people of the land, folk stories, tradition. Democracy was
seen as a political system that enfranchised the individual, or
alternatively, as seen though Fascism, the embodiment of the will of
the people as manifested through a supreme leader. Just as in Europe,
these conflicting views are reflected in the history of modern China.
Mitter describes the changes in Chinese thinking through a
re-evaluation of the writings of a handful of significant writers,
Zou Taofen, Lu Xun, Ding Ling, and others, and the way these were
interpreted at different times. He also draws parallels between Mao
Zedung and his views of communism and that of Stalin, Gorbachev, and
the disintegrating Soviet empire. Using a very broad brush, Rana
Mitter not only wrote a fascinating account of modern China, but
provided an insight into the key developments of world history.
No comments:
Post a Comment